Monday, November 17, 2014

Germination Experiments

Investigations in Germination
by Sci 4 Oppy & Spirit

We have been studying germination. Germination is the stage when the seed sprouts - the seed coat splits and the radicle comes out. We were trying to find out what would work best for alfalfa seeds to germinate.

IMG_5561.JPG IMG_5591.JPG

We had these hypotheses, seeds need:

  • need water to germinate (wwc)
  • need light to germinate (ds)
  • need soil to germinate (es)
  • need carbon dioxide to germinate (al)
  • need nitrogen to germinate (al)
  • need potassium to germinate (ar)
  • need phosphorous to germinate (jrs)
  • need oxygen to germinate (lt)
  • needs proper temperature (ar)
  • needs bacteria to germinate (es)
  • needs proper pH (es)

*“proper” amount may vary by species of plants

To test our hypotheses we glued 5 seeds to a piece of circular filter paper and put that in a petri dish. The petri dishes went into a container with water about 1 cm deep.

IMG_5592.JPG

In our first trial, we put seeds in water and under constant light. We also put seeds under the light without water. The seeds that were dry did not germinate. The seeds that were wet germinated in two days. From this we concluded that seeds need water to trigger germination.
Screen Shot 2014-11-03 at 11.37.52 AM.png

In our second trial, we asked, do they need light. We put the seeds in a dark cupboard to test this. The seeds germinated without light, but the cotyledons didn’t turn green, they were a pale yellow instead. The hypocotyls were white and very long. This tells us that seeds don’t need light to trigger germination. We think the hypocotyls were so long because they were trying to reach light.

Screen Shot 2014-11-03 at 11.36.54 AM.png

In the third trial, we tested how temperature would affect germination. We put one set of seeds in an incubator at 35°C and another set in the refrigerator at 18°C. The seeds in the incubator germinated faster than at room temperature. Most of the seeds in the refrigerator did not germinate at all. The ones that did, grew v-e-r-y s-l-o-w-l-y. So, seeds like warmer temperatures to germinate. We wondered if the embryos in the cold seeds were still alive. We moved them to the room temperature and they germinated. The embryos were still alive.

Our fourth trial tested if the seeds could germinate in salt water. We made salt water solutions of 10 g/L, 5 g/L, 2 ½ g/L and 1 ¼ g/L. Only 7 of 40 seeds germinated at 5 or 10 g/L after 5 days. We moved these seeds to freshwater to see if the embryos were still alive. After 2 days, 6 more seeds germinated when moved to the fresh water for a total of 13 of 40 seeds. In 2 ½ and 1 ¼ g/L, most of the seeds germinated after two days. So that means the embryos can tolerate salt water at a low level. Less than 2 ½ g/L.

Our fifth experiment was to see if seeds needed air to germinate. We put seeds in a test tube completely filled with water and no air bubbles and put a rubber stopper to seal the test tube. After 5 days, the seeds had swelled up and the seed coats had lost color, but no germination. We put these seeds in petri dishes to see if the embryos had drowned or suffocated. We found that some of them were still able to germinate.
IMG_5594.JPG

Doing these experiments, we learned that seeds need certain things to trigger germination. We also learned that science takes time. You can’t rush an experiment or you will mess things up. Sometimes you have to wait a few days to get your data. Experiments have to be carefully planned out. You can’t just say, “Let’s go!” and jump into action. You have to plan before you can do science. We also learned that the most important part of an experiment is the control. We have to have a control to see if there is any difference in the experiments. Our control was seeds germinated in “regular” conditions: room temperature, water and constant light.

12 comments:

  1. This was a great set of investigations. You all did some excellent scientific work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We are finishing this study for now. We will grow plants through their whole life cycle in the spring. Up next: our study of nutrition.

      Delete
  2. In science we've learned that germination and growth are different things. You might think seeds need light to germinate, but they only need water and air.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Seeds need water to germinate, but they don't like salt water. When we did the salt water experiment, the seeds acted like humans and didn't process the salt water correctly.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I used to think that just what I heard that plants needed light and soil. When I did the lab I found all kinds of reasons why plants need the different things they need.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am very impressed with the well done research by these groups. It is very detailed, rich in information and the drawings are fabulous. I have a question: do you always use Celsius in your science experiments as temperature measurement? Good job 4V!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great work groups, you did a wonderful job of completing all the steps that make an experiment successful!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I enjoyed reading your results. I especially enjoyed learning that seed which had been too cold to germinate, when warmed up, could germinate. Excellent design idea.
    Howie (Bernie's dad)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I liked the way the scientific method was used. Very well explained and detailed.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I wonder if there are some plants whose seeds prefer water with higher salt levels. (Francesca's dad and her brother Luca)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I was impressed with how carefully you planned the trials! You were able to figure out the essential needs of alfalfa seeds in order to get them to germinate. I wonder if other seeds would have different needs...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Jim Bracchitta (Griff's dad)November 17, 2014 at 4:54 PM

    Wow. This is totally fascinating! We have a small garden plot in the summer in our co-op but I never really understood how all those delicious veggies really come to be. Of course, in our backyard, we have lots of light, water, air and not a lot of salt water, so now that makes sense.
    Thanks 4V -- terrific work!

    ReplyDelete

Please make sure all comments are "child friendly" and appropriate for general audience. Thanks.